Holding Two Offices: What Does the Constitution Say About an Office of Profit?
Holding Two Offices: What Does the Constitution Say About an Office of Profit?
Why in News?
The Bihar Governor’s office has asked whether the appointment of Food and Consumer Protection Minister Ashok Choudhary as an Assistant Professor at A. N. College, Patna, could disqualify him from membership of the Legislative Council on the ground of holding an office of profit. It has also asked whether he can retain a lien on the university post while serving as a minister and a Member of the Legislative Council (MLC).
Why in news
In February 2026, Ashok Choudhary took up the post of Assistant Professor of Political Science at A. N. College, Patna. He went on leave the following day to continue carrying out his duties as an MLC and minister.
- The university’s Vice-Chancellor referred two questions to the Governor’s Secretariat. Can Choudhary retain a lien on the university post? Can the Assistant Professor’s post be treated as an office of profit even if he does not draw a salary?
What Is a Lien?
A lien is a government employee’s right to hold a permanent post to which they have been substantively appointed. Subject to the applicable service rules, it allows the employee to retain their claim to the post during an absence and return to it later. In its note dated 31 October 2026, Raj Bhavan stated that Choudhary could not claim a lien on the post because he was still on probation.
- Provision for special leave. Section 68(2) of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, grants special leave to university teachers and employees elected to Parliament or a State Legislature. It protects their increments, promotions and seniority, and entitles them to return to university service after their legislative term ends.
- Raj Bhavan’s interpretation. According to Raj Bhavan, the provision applies to employees elected while already in university service. A sitting legislator appointed to a university post later does not receive this protection. Choudhary disagreed and cited instances at Magadh University where, he said, employees had been granted a lien while on probation.
- Entitlement to salary. In considering whether the Assistant Professor’s post could lead to disqualification, Raj Bhavan focused on whether the post carries an entitlement to salary or other financial benefits. Actual payment is immaterial to that assessment.
What Is an Office of Profit?
The Constitution does not define an ‘office of profit’. In the context of disqualification of MPs and members of State Legislatures, the term broadly refers to a post under the Union or a State Government that can yield a financial benefit. The assessment takes into account the nature of the post, its relationship with the government, the financial benefits it carries and any statutory exemption.
The concept has its roots in 18th-century Britain. Members of the House of Commons who accepted certain salaried ministerial offices had to vacate their seats and contest a by-election to return to the House. The rule was relaxed in 1919, and the requirement to contest a by-election was abolished in 1926.
What Are the Constitutional Provisions?
| Article | Who Does It Apply To? | Provision |
| Article 102(1)(a) | Members of both Houses of Parliament | A person who holds an office of profit under the Union or a State Government is disqualified from membership of Parliament. Parliament may exempt an office from this disqualification by law. |
| Article 191(1)(a) | Members of State Legislative Assemblies and Legislative Councils | A person who holds an office of profit under the Union or a State Government is disqualified from membership of a State Legislature. The State Legislature concerned may exempt an office from this disqualification by law. |
The explanations to both articles clarify that holding office as a Union or State Minister does not, by itself, amount to holding an office of profit.
Who Decides Questions of Disqualification?
- Members of Parliament. Under Article 103, the President decides whether a sitting MP has incurred a disqualification under Article 102(1). The President must obtain the opinion of the Election Commission of India and act in accordance with it.
- Members of State Legislatures. Under Article 192, the Governor decides whether a sitting member of a Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council has incurred a disqualification under Article 191(1). The Governor must obtain the opinion of the Election Commission of India and act in accordance with it. This procedure applies when a question arises about an MLC holding an office of profit.
Parliament (Prevention of Disqualification) Act, 1959
· Section 3 of the Act specifies offices and categories of offices whose holders are exempt from disqualification for membership of Parliament under Article 102(1)(a). The Schedule determines the scope of the exemption for certain offices. Under Article 191(1)(a), State Legislatures may enact separate laws exempting specified offices for their members.
· Section 2(a) defines ‘compensatory allowance’. It covers specified payments intended to reimburse expenses incurred in carrying out the duties of an office. These include a daily allowance within the prescribed limit, a conveyance allowance, a house-rent allowance and a travelling allowance.
Two Cases Involving Academic Appointments
· Anupam Hazra case (2015). The Joint Committee on Offices of Profit considered the autonomy of Visva-Bharati University, its appointment procedure and the source of payment. It concluded that the Assistant Professor’s post held by Trinamool Congress MP Anupam Hazra was not an office of profit under the government. Holding the post therefore did not disqualify him from membership of Parliament.
· Manmohan Singh case (2016). Panjab University offered former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh the Jawaharlal Nehru Chair. The Joint Committee on Offices of Profit concluded that he could accept the offer without affecting his Rajya Sabha membership. It considered the nature of the appointment, the daily allowance of ₹5,000 and the university’s autonomy.
Other Grounds for Disqualification from Membership
Constitutional Grounds
Under Articles 102(1) and 191(1), a person may also be disqualified from membership of Parliament or a State Legislature on any of the following grounds.
- A competent court has declared the person to be of unsound mind, and the declaration remains in force.
- The person is an undischarged insolvent, meaning they have yet to be legally discharged from insolvency.
- The person is not a citizen of India, has voluntarily acquired the citizenship of a foreign State or has acknowledged allegiance to a foreign State.
- The person is disqualified under a law enacted by Parliament.
Articles 102(2) and 191(2) also provide for disqualification on grounds of defection under the Tenth Schedule.
Disqualification Under the Representation of the People Act, 1951
- Section 8 : Conviction for an offence. Conviction for an offence specified in the Act leads to disqualification for the prescribed period. Under Section 8(3), a person sentenced to imprisonment for at least two years for any other offence is disqualified from the date of conviction and remains disqualified for six years after release. In Lily Thomas v. Union of India (2013), the Supreme Court struck down Section 8(4) as unconstitutional. That provision had given sitting MPs and members of State Legislatures three months of protection after conviction. If they filed an appeal or an application for revision within that period, disqualification could be deferred until it was decided.
- Section 10 : Office in a company or corporation with government shareholding. A person who serves as the managing agent, manager or secretary of a company or corporation is disqualified if the appropriate government holds at least 25 per cent of its share capital. This provision excludes co-operative societies.
Disqualification Under the Anti-Defection Law
The Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Act, 1985, inserted the Tenth Schedule to curb political defections. A member may be disqualified in any of the following circumstances.
- A member voluntarily gives up membership of their political party.
- A member votes or abstains from voting in the House contrary to a direction issued by their political party or its authorised representative without prior permission, and the party or its authorised representative does not condone the action within 15 days.
- An independent member joins a political party after being elected.
- A nominated member joins a political party more than six months after taking their seat in the House.
Exceptions
- Merger. A merger is deemed to have taken place for the purposes of the Tenth Schedule if at least two-thirds of the members of the legislature party concerned agree to it. An earlier provision also exempted a split involving at least one-third of the members of a legislature party. The Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003, removed that exception.
- Speaker or Chairman. Subject to the prescribed conditions, a Speaker or Chairman may give up membership of their political party upon assuming office and rejoin the same party after leaving office without incurring disqualification for defection.
Decision and judicial review. Under Paragraph 6 of the Tenth Schedule, the Speaker or Chairman of the House concerned decides questions of disqualification on grounds of defection. In Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu (1992), the Supreme Court held that this decision is subject to judicial review.
Practice Question
Question. Under which Article of the Constitution is a question concerning the disqualification of a sitting Member of a Legislative Council for holding an office of profit referred to the Governor for a decision?
(A) Article 102
(B) Article 103
(C) Article 191
(D) Article 192
Answer : (D)
Explanation. Article 191(1)(a) makes holding an office of profit a ground for disqualification. Under Article 192, the Governor obtains the opinion of the Election Commission of India and acts in accordance with it.
More Current Affairs - Daily
- India’s State Capacity Stagnation: The Missing Link in Reform 21 Nov 2026
- Surveillance Pricing : How Is Personal Data Used to Set Prices? 21 Nov 2026
- The Price of War: West Asia Crisis Is Raising India’s Energy Import Bill 21 Nov 2026
- Assessing Health Product Claims : From Hypothesis to Scientific Evidence 21 Nov 2026